Competitor Cost Benchmark

Food Ingredients

Competitive Benchmark

Techno-Economic Analysis

A food ingredients company competes with a rival technology that makes the same product. The rival's costs are not public. In four weeks, Roebling built an engineering-based model of the rival process in the U.S. Midwest and in China, with tariffs and shipping included, resulting in an independent cost basis across 80+ scenarios and a ranked view of what drives the competitor's cost.

Fermentation broth split into U.S. Midwest and China halves
Fermentation broth split into U.S. Midwest and China halves

4 weeks

from kickoff to a working cost model of the competitor's process

80+ scenarios

across locations, feedstocks, equipment options, and production scales

U.S. vs. China

compared with tariffs, shipping, and local labor productivity built in

Challenge

The company's planning and investment case depends on a number it cannot look up: what the rival technology costs to build and run at commercial scale. Public data is thin. The one existing facility's reported capital cost reflects a different time and place than a new build today.

Solution

Roebling reconstructed the rival process from first principles, from mass and energy balance through sized equipment, and costed it with budgetary raw material quotes and its own equipment cost database. Where public data stopped, Roebling's fermentation engineers made and documented the calls.

Results

The company now has an independent cost basis for its main competing technology, with every location, feedstock, and equipment case carried through to CapEx and fully loaded COGS. Tornado diagrams rank the variables that move the competitor's cost most, showing where that cost is most exposed.

Deliverables

Process & Engineering

Block Flow Diagram

The alternative process from fermentation through final product.

Mass & Energy Balance

Material and energy flows at each production scale.

Sized Equipment List

Equipment sized for the commercial facility.

Equipment Trade-Off Analysis

A key equipment choice compared on CapEx, OpEx, and utility use.

Labor Model & Staffing Plan

Staffing adjusted for local labor productivity.

Cost & Economics

Techno-Economic Model

A dynamic model with a feedstock toggle so it can run on either feedstock.

Raw Material Quotes

Budgetary quotes collected for raw materials.

CapEx Estimates

Estimated at +/-30% for the U.S. Midwest and +/-50% for China.

COGS Breakdown

Direct and fully loaded COGS, including tariff and shipping costs.

Pro Forma Financial Model

Sources and uses, with fully loaded COGS that includes the cost of capital.

Scenario Analyses & Tornado Diagrams

Stacked upside and downside cases at three scales, with tornados for direct and fully loaded COGS.

Benchmark & Reporting

Location Comparison

A U.S. Midwest facility compared against a facility in China.

Feedstock Comparison

Two feedstock strategies compared on the same basis.

Existing Facility Cost Perspective

A high-level view of an existing facility's capital cost from public sources, alongside an estimate for a similar U.S. build today.

TEA Summary Report

Findings and key cost drivers for planning and investment decisions.

The Approach

Engineering judgment where public data stops.

  • One model carried every location, feedstock, and equipment case through to CapEx, direct COGS, and fully loaded COGS on the same basis.

  • Budgetary raw material quotes and Roebling’s equipment cost database grounded the estimate.

  • Tariff, shipping, and local labor productivity were built into the location comparison.

  • Stacked upside and downside cases ran at three production scales.

What the team says

"Much of the data we needed was not publicly available, so we had to apply engineering judgment to fill the gaps. Our team's process engineering and fermentation project background gave us confidence in those calls, and they were key to the success of this project."

Team photo of Crystal Bleecher

Crystal Bleecher

SVP, Process Engineering, Roebling

"Much of the data we needed was not publicly available, so we had to apply engineering judgment to fill the gaps. Our team's process engineering and fermentation project background gave us confidence in those calls, and they were key to the success of this project."

Team photo of Crystal Bleecher

Crystal Bleecher

SVP, Process Engineering, Roebling

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get the latest Roebling articles, webinar invites, and product updates straight to your inbox.

By subscribing you agree to Roebling’s privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

Copyright © 2026 Roebling. All Rights Reserved.

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get the latest Roebling articles, webinar invites, and product updates straight to your inbox.

By subscribing you agree to Roebling’s privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

Copyright © 2026 Roebling. All Rights Reserved.

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get the latest Roebling articles, webinar invites, and product updates straight to your inbox.

By subscribing you agree to Roebling’s privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

Copyright © 2026 Roebling. All Rights Reserved.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to improve site functionality. Some cookies help us understand how visitors use our site.