Gas Fermentation FOAK vs. Nth Plant
Alternative Protein
Gas Fermentation
FOAK vs. Nth Plant
Gas fermentation uses bacteria to turn gases into single cell protein for human food. Roebling was hired to study two routes, one fed by methane and one by CO2 and hydrogen. In seven weeks, Roebling modeled both on one design basis, resulting in an independent view of what a first-of-a-kind plant and an nth plant would cost to build and run, and how long each would take to bring online.
50% faster
delivering two models, two project schedules, and a memo report
2 routes
methane-fed and CO2-fed, modeled on the same design basis
100+ scenarios
evaluated across both models, including FOAK and nth plant cases
Challenge
The purpose of the study was to find out what a commercial-scale facility for each route would cost to build and run, how long it would take to bring online, and what would limit how fast the industry could scale. Public cost data at this scale was thin, and published estimates used different assumptions. The study needed one consistent, independent basis.
Solution
Roebling built two dynamic TEA models from a mass and energy balance and a sized equipment list, covering the full facility, including utilities and on-site gas production. Each route was costed as a first-of-a-kind plant and as an nth plant, with project schedules for both. Roebling also compared stirred tank, air-lift, and U-tube fermentors, and sterile versus non-sterile designs.
Results
On-site gas production was a major share of CapEx, especially for the CO2 route. Fermentation cooling and oxygen supply were the largest power users for both routes. Siting near existing industrial gas pipelines could save significant cost and time. The report evaluated which equipment could be fabricated and sourced domestically, and flagged what could not.
Deliverables
Techno-Economic Models
Methane Gas Fermentation TEA
A dynamic model of a greenfield, commercial-scale methane-fed facility.
CO2 Gas Fermentation TEA
The CO2-fed route on the same design basis, with on-site hydrogen and CO2 supply.
Mass & Energy Balance
Continuous fermentation and the full downstream process, through dried and packaged bulk protein.
Sized Equipment List
Equipment for the process, supporting utilities, and on-site gas production.
Cost & Schedule
FOAK vs. Nth Plant Cost
The cost of a first-of-a-kind plant compared with an nth plant built after many others.
Project Schedules
A FOAK plant with on-site gas production and an nth plant supplied by pipeline, from engineering through ramp-up.
CapEx Breakdowns
FEL-1 estimates at +/-30%, including bulk material quantities and building size.
OpEx Breakdowns
Media, utilities, labor, and overhead for each route.
Tornado Diagrams
COGS and CapEx sensitivities for each model.
Design & Reporting
Fermentor Type Comparison
Stirred tank, air-lift, and U-tube fermentors evaluated for gas fermentation.
Sterility Design Option
Sterile versus non-sterile fermentors, with the cost of the choice quantified.
Siting & Sourcing Assessment
The benefit of siting near industrial gas pipelines, and which equipment could be sourced in the U.S.
Report Memo
Results, calculation methods, assumptions, and technical discussion topics.
The Approach
The comparison FOAK companies need to plan funding and timelines.
Both routes were modeled on the same design basis, so they compare directly.
The models were built bottom up from a mass and energy balance and a sized equipment list, not scaled from published estimates.
Roebling’s capital project experience covered the whole facility, including utilities, gas production, and the project schedule.
Subject matter experts and industry companies were interviewed to test key assumptions.
The models are dynamic, so the client can change inputs and test its own scenarios.
What the team says
We value your privacy
We use cookies to improve site functionality. Some cookies help us understand how visitors use our site.


